1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 1
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 2
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 3
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 4
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 5
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 6
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 7
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 8
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 9
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 10
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 11
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 12
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 13
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 14
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 15
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 16
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 17
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 18
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 19
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 20
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 21
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 22
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 23
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 24
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 25
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 26
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 27
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 28
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 29
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 30
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 31
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 32
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 33
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 34
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 35
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 36
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 37
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ON photo 38
New1 / 38
$475,000
1257 Paint Lake Road • Lake of Bays, ONNew
Courtesy of RE/MAX ESCARPMENT REALTY INC.
2
Bedrooms
1
Bathroom
< 700
Square feet
5
Parking

About this home

Muskoka cottage with private dock and Lake of Bays access. Exceptional value in a sought-afterlocation. Welcome to 1257 Paint Lake Road . An increasingly rare opportunity to own an affordable cottage with real waterfront use on one of Muskoka's most desirable lake systems. This 2-bedroom, 1-bath cottage is ready to enjoy immediately, offering a warm, inviting interior with a WETT-certified wood-burning fireplace and a bright sunroom for added living and sleeping space. Set back from the road with a forested backdrop, it delivers privacy and a relaxed cottage feel. Your 58 feet of deeded shoreline just across the road features a clean, sandy-bottom entry and private dock, ideal for swimming, boating, and long summer days on the water. Paint Lake offers direct boating access into Lake of Bays, unlocking extended exploration, waterfront destinations, and full-day adventures. With year-round access on a municipally maintained paved road, plus a drilled well, septic system, and detached garage for storage, this property is both practical and easy to enjoy from day one. In a market where many options are water-access only, vacant land, or priced significantly higher, this property stands out as a smart entry into Muskoka ownership with immediate use and long-term upside. The lot also offers strong potential to expand or build a larger custom two-storey cottage, whether for personal use or as an investment rental, while still enjoying the existing structure today. Opportunities like this are limited. Secure your place in Muskoka paradise now and start making the most of the seasons ahead. If you're looking for a summer retreat, a family gathering place where cherished memories are made, or a property with future upside, this is your opportunity to step into Muskoka cottage living today, with the flexibility to grow into something more.

Property details

Property type
Detached
Style
Bungalow
Approx. age (yrs)
51-99
Total rooms
7
Lot size
105 × 152.7 ft
Property taxes
$1,414 (2025)
Occupancy
Flexible
Days on market
2
Status
Active
MLS®

Property history

Recently sold nearby

Listing data last updated: Sep 12, 2026, 12:34 p.m. EDT via TRREB IDX.

First listed: Sep 12, 2026, 12:34 p.m. EDT.