4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 1
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 2
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 3
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 4
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 5
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 6
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 7
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 8
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 9
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 10
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 11
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 12
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 13
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 14
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 15
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 16
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 17
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 18
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 19
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 20
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 21
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 22
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 23
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 24
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 25
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 26
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 27
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 28
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 29
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 30
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 31
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 32
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 33
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 34
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 35
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 36
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 37
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 38
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 39
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 40
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 41
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 42
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 43
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 44
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 45
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 46
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 47
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 48
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 49
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON photo 50
1 / 50
$2,258,888
4421 5th Line • Bradford West Gwillimbury, ONNew
Courtesy of ENGEL & VOLKERS TORONTO CITY
4
Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
3500-5000
Square feet
16
Parking

About this home

Truly a one of a kind property - The Carswell House is a remarkable Georgian-style home with immense history and character. Built circa 1840's by one of Simcoe County's earliest residents, Andrew Carswell, this residence has been home to just 6 families over 180+ years. Historic character is preserved throughout, including original pine floors, original main floor windows, cross-and-bible doors with original box locks, a heated cobblestone kitchen floor, wood-burning fireplaces, restored woodwork, elegant masonry, and original stone foundation. This grand home offers 3,530 sqft of above grade living space, plus a usable excavated basement with separate walk-up entrance. Upstairs, historic elegance continues with soaring 12 ft ceilings and restored wood trim. 3 spacious bedrooms plus a 4th loft bedroom feature individual natural gas heaters. The board-and-batten addition provides a mudroom with brand-new oak hardwood floors, main-floor laundry, and a recently renovated full bathroom. Recent updates include a durable metal roof, new UV water filtration system, whole home Generac standby generator, and 400 amp electrical service. Enjoy rare natural gas service in a rural setting! Set on an elevated ridge, enjoy spectacular southern views over South Simcoe's rolling hills. The 5.87 acre property features a pond, stream, pear and apple trees, a detached 2-car garage, and spectacular privacy. The extra-large barn was rebuilt in 2002 and offers 3 floors, an electrical sub-panel, and water connection from a separate well. Ideal for a workshop, storage, horses or other animals, tractors, vehicles, or even for business use! Large barn doors enhance usability of the lower level. Enjoy peaceful country living within minutes of Bond Head, Bradford, and Schomberg, with excellent Highway 400 access on 5th Line and close to Bradford GO Station! A rare opportunity to own a distinctive 19th-century home, preserved in its Georgian character and set on a serene country property.

Property details

Property type
Detached
Style
2-Storey
Approx. age (yrs)
100+
Total rooms
10
Lot size
371.63 × 691.96 ft
Property taxes
$11,856.46 (2026)
Occupancy
Flexible
Days on market
46
Status
Active
MLS®

Property history

Recently sold nearby

Listing data last updated: Sep 24, 2026, 3:58 p.m. EDT via TRREB IDX.

First listed: Aug 11, 2026, 9:52 a.m. EDT.